Differences between revisions 55 and 56
⇤ ← Revision 55 as of 2012-04-02 14:27:17 →
Size: 14720
Editor: miyoki
Comment:
← Revision 56 as of 2012-04-02 14:27:53 → ⇥
Size: 14722
Editor: miyoki
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 36: Line 36:
|||||||||| ||||||||||||

External Review (in English)

Date: April 17(Tue) - April 20(Fri), 2012

Location and access: ICRR U-tokyo, Kashiwa campus, 6F large conference room http://www.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp/access/index_eng.html

Reference Documents

System Engineering Management Plan (I.Nakatani and SEO)

GUIDELINES FOR THE EXTERNAL REVIEW ON THE KAGRA PROJECT (I.Nakatani)

Program and Presentation Files

4/17

Time

Title

Speaker

Presentation

Template File

10:00-10:20 (20)

(SEO):Objectives and Scope of this External Review

S.Kawamura

JGW-

10:20-10:40 (20)

(EC ):KAGRA Project Status

T.Kajita

JGW-

10:40-10:55 (15)

(EC ):Budget Status

M.Ohashi

JGW-

10:55-11:15 (20)

(EC ):Program Advisory Board Report and our Response

T.Kajita

JGW-

11:15-11:35 (20)

(EC ):International Collaboration Status

K.Kuroda

JGW-

Lunch (11:35 ~ 13:00)

13:00-13:25

(SEO):System Engineering Management Plan (SEMP)

I.Nakatani

JGW-

13:00-13:25 (25)

(SEO):KAGRA Sensitivity with Practical Parameters

K.Somiya

JGW-

13:25-13:50 (25)

(SEO):Interface Control

K.Somiya

JGW-

13:50-14:05 (15)

(SEO):Layout

S.Miyoki

JGW-

14:20-14:50 (30)

(SEO):Roadmap and Bottom-up Schedule

M.Ando

JGW-

Coffee Break (14:50 ~ 15:10)

15:10-15:25 (15)

(SEO):Performance Measurement System

S.Miyoki

JGW-

15:25-15:40 (15)

(SEO):Risk Management

M.Ando

JGW-

15:40-15:50 (10)

(SEO):Inventory Management

S.Miyoki

JGW-

15:50-16:00 (10)

(SEO):Changes in Human Resources and Sub-systems

S.Kawamura

JGW-

4/18

Time

Title

Speaker

File

10:00-10:40 (40)

(VAC):Vacuum

Y.Saito

JGW-

10:40-11:30 (50)

(CRY1):Cryogenic System

T.suzuki, N.Kimura

JGW-

11:30-12:00 (30)

(CRY2):Cryo-payload

K.Yamamoto

JGW-

Lunch (12:00 ~ 13:30)

13:30-14:00 (30)

(TUN):Tunnel

T.Uchiyama

JGW-

14:40-14:40 (40)

(VIS1):Vibration Isolation

R.Takahashi

JGW-

Coffee Break (14:40 ~ 15:00)

15:00-15:40

(VIS2):Vibration Isolation

R.Desalvo

JGW-

15:40-16:20

(GEO):Geophysical Strainmeter

A.Araya

JGW-

18:00-20:00

Banquet

4/19

Time

Title

Speaker

File

10:00-10:50 (50)

(MIF1):Length Control

Y.Aso

JGW-

10:50-11:40 (50)

(MIF2):Alignment Control

Y.Aso et.al.

JGW-

11:40-12:00 (20)

Interlock

Y.Aso et. al.

JGW-

Lunch (12:00 ~ 13:30)

13:30-14:10 (40)

(IOO):Input Output Optics

S.Telada

JGW-

14:10-14:50 (40)

(AOS):Aux. Optics

T.Akutsu

JGW-

Coffee Break (14:50 ~ 15:10)

15:10-15:50 (40)

(DIG):Digital System

O.Miyakawa

JGW-

15:50-16:30 (40)

(DAS):Data Anakysis

N.Kanda

JGW-

4/20

Time

Title

Speaker

File

10:00-10:40 (40)

(LAS):Laser

N. Mio

JGW-

10:40-11:20 (40)

(MIR):Mirror

N. Mio

JGW-

11:20-12:00 (40)

(MIF4):Detector Characterization

K.Hayama

JGW-

Lunch (12:00 ~ 13:30)

13:30-

Closed Session

Reviewers

Reviewers

Name

Affiliation

Remarks

Masaki Ando

LCGT/ Kyoto University

Deputy chief of secretariat

Stefan Ballmer

LSC/ Syracuse University

Alessandro Bertolini

LSC/ Albert-Einstein-Institut Hannover

Raffaele Flaminio

Virgo/ Laboratoire des Matériaux Avancés

Andreas Freise

GEO/ University of Birmingham

Seiji Kawamura

LCGT/ ICRR, NAOJ

Chief of secretariat

David Ottaway

ACIGA/ University of Adelaide

Benno Willke

GEO/ Leibniz Universität Hannover

Michael E. Zucker

LIGO-Lab/ Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Chair

Note for presenters (in Japanese)

  • 1. Overview
    • 1-1. Definition and scope of the subsystem
      • （該当サブシステムの一般的な定義、特にどのサブシステムに属するか明白でない項目についても明記）
    • 1-2. Important interface
      • （該当サブシステムと他のサブシステムとの間のインターフェースについての一般的な記述、特に重要なものについては詳述）
    • 1-3. Design phase
      • （iKAGRAの最終設計、bKAGRAの予備設計という範疇に入らないものを明記）
  • 2. iKAGRA
    • 2-1. Target specifications（目標仕様、重要なスペックだけでよい）
    • 2-2. Final design
      • デザインの記述、最終設計により目標仕様を満たすことができることの説明を加えてください。
    • 2-3. Schedule
    • 2-4. Quality assurance
      • 製造過程において性能を保障するための方策
      • 購入・製作物品の性能確認方法
    • 2-5. Installation scenario
    • 2-6. Risk management（各リスクを可能性と重大さに応じて評価、対策を講じる（SEMP参照））
  • 3. bKAGRA
    • 3-1. Requirements
    • 3-2. Preliminary design
      • 予備設計により要求値を満たすことができることの説明を含めてください
    • 3-3. Schedule
    • 3-4. Prototype test (if any)（予備設計の妥当性を確かめるためのプロトタイプテストの計画）
    • 3-5. Quality assurance
      • 製造過程において性能を保障するための方策
      • 購入・製作物品の性能確認方法
    • 3-6. Installation scenario
    • 3-7. Risk management
  • Appendix
    • A. Design changes that have been made with the suggestions in the 1st external review (if any)
      • （前回の外部レビューで推奨された案件に従って設計の変更を行ったものを列挙）
    • B. Items that have been reduced in cost (if any)
      • （以前の設計でオーバースペックだったが、予算削減のためにスペックダウンした項目
    • C.Human resources
      • 現在のマンパワー（人名）をエフォート（％で表示）付きで記述してください。
      • 今後必要とされるマンパワー（人数）を2018年まで1年ごとに表示してください。

Date: February 28(Mon) - March 4(Fri), 2011

Location and access: ICRR U-tokyo, Kashiwa campus, 6F large conference room

http://www.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp/access/index_eng.html

Review documents

Subgroup name

Document number

Analog Electronics

JGW-T1100364

Cryogenics

JGW-T1100366

Data Analysis

JGW-T1100367

Detector Configuration

JGW-T1100368

Digital system

JGW-T1100359

Input Output Optics

JGW-T1100369

Laser

JGW-T1100370

Main Interferometer

JGW-T1100363

Mirror

JGW-T1100371

Tunnel

JGW-T1100362

Vacuum

JGW-T1100372

Vibration Isolation

JGW-T1100365

Program

2/28

Time

Title

Speaker

File

9:50-10:05

Opening Talk

T. Kajita

10:05-10:10

Introduction of External Review

S. Kawamura

JGW-M1100374

10:10-12:00

Detector Configuration & Roadmap 1

K. Somiya, M. Ando

JGW-G1100375

Lunch

13:30-15:30

Detector Configuration & Roadmap 2

K. Somiya, M. Ando

JGW-G1100377

Coffee Break

16:00-18:00

Data Analysis

N. Kanda

JGW-G1100378

3/1

Time

Title

Speaker

File

10:00-12:00

Main Interferometer 1

Y. Aso

JGW-G1100379

Lunch

13:30-14:30

Main Interferometer 2

Y. Aso

JGW-G1100379

Coffee Break

15:00-17:00

Input/Output Optics

S. Talada

JGW-G1100380

3/2

Time

Title

Speaker

File

10:00-12:00

Vibration Isolation 1

R. Takahashi

JGW-G1100383

Lunch

13:30-14:30

Cryogenics

T. Suzuki

JGW-G1100387

14:30-15:00

Vacuum

Y. Saito

JGW-G1100381

15:00-16:00

Tunnel

T. Uchiyama

JGW-G1100382

Coffee Break

Extra talk 1

CLIO

T. Uchiyama

JGW-G1100390

Extra talk 2

TAMA SAS

R. Takahashi

JGW-G1100389

17:30-18:00

Geophysics Interferometer

A. Araya

JGW-G1100384

3/3

Time

Title

Speaker

File

10:00-11:00

Laser

N. Mio

JGW-G1100392

11:00-12:00

Mirror

N. Mio

JGW-G1100391

Lunch

13:30-14:15

Analog Electronics

S. Moriwaki

JGW-G1100393

14:15-15:00

Digital System

O. Miyakawa

JGW-G1100388

15:00-15:30

Vibration Isolation 2

R. DeSalvo

JGW-G1100385

Break

18:00-20:00

Banquet

3/4

10:00-12:00

Discussion among reviewers 1

Lunch

13:30-15:30

Discussion among reviewers 2

Adjourn

Reviewers

Name

Affiliation

Remarks

Masaki Ando

LCGT/ Kyoto University

Deputy chief of secretariat

Stefan Ballmer

LSC/ Syracuse University

Alessandro Bertolini

LSC/ Albert-Einstein-Institut Hannover

Raffaele Flaminio

Virgo/ Laboratoire des Matériaux Avancés

Andreas Freise

GEO/ University of Birmingham

Warren Johnson

LSC/ Louisiana State University

Seiji Kawamura

LCGT/ ICRR, NAOJ

Chief of secretariat

David Ottaway

ACIGA/ University of Adelaide

Benno Willke

GEO/ Leibniz Universität Hannover

Michael E. Zucker

LIGO-Lab/ Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Chair

LCGT/Meeting/Reviews/External (last edited 2021-09-26 19:08:47 by miyoki)