External Review (in English)
Date: April 17(Tue) - April 20(Fri), 2012
Location and access: ICRR U-tokyo, Kashiwa campus, 6F large conference room http://www.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp/access/index_eng.html
Reference Documents
System Engineering Management Plan (I.Nakatani and SEO)
GUIDELINES FOR THE EXTERNAL REVIEW ON THE KAGRA PROJECT (I.Nakatani)
Bottom Up Schedule (M.Ando and SEO)
Risk Management List(M.Ando and SEO)
Performance Measurement(M.Ando -> S.Miyoki and SEO)
Interface Control Document (K.Somiya and SEO)
Program and Presentation/Template Files
4/17 (Tue) |
||||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
Presentation |
Document |
10:00-10:20 (20) |
(SEO):Objectives and Scope of this External Review |
S.Kawamura |
|
|
10:20-10:40 (20) |
(EC ):KAGRA Project Status |
T.Kajita |
|
|
10:40-10:55 (15) |
(EC ):Budget Status |
M.Ohashi |
|
|
10:55-11:15 (20) |
(EC ):Program Advisory Board Report and our Response |
T.Kajita |
|
|
11:15-11:35 (20) |
(EC ):International Collaboration Status |
K.Kuroda |
|
|
|
Lunch (11:35 ~ 13:00) |
|
|
|
13:00-13:25 (25) |
(SEO):System Engineering Management Plan (SEMP) |
I.Nakatani |
|
|
13:25-13:50 (25) |
(SEO):KAGRA Sensitivity with Practical Parameters |
K.Somiya |
|
|
13:50-14:05 (15) |
(SEO):Interface Control |
K.Somiya |
|
|
14:04-14:20 (15) |
(SEO):Layout |
S.Miyoki |
|
|
|
Coffee Break (14:20 ~ 14:40) |
|
|
|
14:40-15:10 (30) |
(SEO):Roadmap and Bottom-up Schedule |
M.Ando |
|
|
15:10-15:25 (15) |
(SEO):Performance Measurement System |
S.Miyoki |
|
|
15:25-15:40 (15) |
(SEO):Risk Management |
M.Ando |
|
|
15:40-15:50 (10) |
(SEO):Inventory Management |
S.Miyoki |
|
|
15:50-16:00 (10) |
(SEO):Changes in Human Resources and Sub-systems |
S.Kawamura |
|
|
4/18 (Wed) |
||||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
Document |
10:00-10:40 (40) |
(VAC):Vacuum |
Y.Saito |
||
10:40-11:30 (50) |
(CRY1):Cryogenic System |
T.Suzuki, N.Kimura |
||
11:30-12:00 (30) |
(CRY2):Cryo-payload |
K.Yamamoto |
||
|
Lunch (12:00 ~ 13:30) |
|
|
|
13:30-14:00 (30) |
(TUN):Tunnel |
T.Uchiyama |
||
14:00-14:40 (40) |
(VIS1):Vibration Isolation |
R.Takahashi |
||
|
Coffee Break (14:40 ~ 15:00) |
|
|
|
15:00-15:40 (40) |
(VIS2):Vibration Isolation |
R.DeSalvo |
|
|
15:40-16:20 (40) |
(GEO):Geophysical Strainmeter |
A.Araya |
||
18:00-20:00 |
Banquet |
|||
4/19 (Thu) |
||||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
Document |
10:00-10:50 (50) |
(MIF1):Length Control |
Y.Aso |
||
10:50-11:40 (50) |
(MIF2):Alignment Control |
Y.Aso et.al. |
|
|
11:40-12:00 (20) |
Interlock |
Y.Aso et. al. |
|
|
|
Lunch (12:00 ~ 13:30) |
|
|
|
13:30-14:10 (40) |
(IOO):Input Output Optics |
S.Telada |
||
14:10-14:50 (40) |
(AOS):Auxiliary Optics |
T.Akutsu |
||
|
Coffee Break (14:50 ~ 15:10) |
|
|
|
15:10-15:50 (40) |
(DIG):Digital System |
O.Miyakawa |
||
15:50-16:30 (40) |
(DAS):Data Analysis |
N.Kanda |
||
4/20 (Fri) |
||||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
Document |
10:00-10:40 (40) |
(LAS):Laser |
N. Mio |
||
10:40-11:20 (40) |
(MIR):Mirror |
N. Mio |
||
11:20-12:00 (40) |
(MIF4):Detector Characterization |
K.Hayama |
||
|
Lunch (12:00 ~ 13:30) |
|
|
|
13:30- |
Closed Session |
Reviewers |
|
|
Reviewers
Name |
Affiliation |
Remarks |
Stefan Ballmer |
LSC/ Syracuse University |
|
Raffaele Flaminio |
Laboratoire des Matériaux Avancés - CNRS/IN2P3 |
|
Andreas Freise |
GEO/ University of Birmingham |
|
Warren Johnson |
LSC/ Louisiana State University |
|
David Ottaway |
ACIGA/ University of Adelaide |
|
Benno Willke |
GEO/ Leibniz Universität Hannover |
|
Michael E. Zucker |
LIGO-Lab/ Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
Chair |
Note for presenters (in Japanese)
- 1. Overview
- 1-1. Definition and scope of the subsystem
- （該当サブシステムの一般的な定義、特にどのサブシステムに属するか明白でない項目についても明記）
- 1-2. Important interface
- （該当サブシステムと他のサブシステムとの間のインターフェースについての一般的な記述、特に重要なものについては詳述）
- 1-3. Design phase
- （iKAGRAの最終設計、bKAGRAの予備設計という範疇に入らないものを明記）
- 1-1. Definition and scope of the subsystem
- 2. iKAGRA
- 2-1. Target specifications（目標仕様、重要なスペックだけでよい）
- 2-2. Final design
- デザインの記述、最終設計により目標仕様を満たすことができることの説明を加えてください。
- 2-3. Schedule
- 2-4. Quality assurance
- 製造過程において性能を保障するための方策
- 購入・製作物品の性能確認方法
- 2-5. Installation scenario
- 2-6. Risk management（各リスクを可能性と重大さに応じて評価、対策を講じる（SEMP参照））
- 3. bKAGRA
- 3-1. Requirements
- 3-2. Preliminary design
- 予備設計により要求値を満たすことができることの説明を含めてください
- 3-3. Schedule
- 3-4. Prototype test (if any)（予備設計の妥当性を確かめるためのプロトタイプテストの計画）
- 3-5. Quality assurance
- 製造過程において性能を保障するための方策
- 購入・製作物品の性能確認方法
- 3-6. Installation scenario
- 3-7. Risk management
- Appendix
- A. Design changes that have been made with the suggestions in the 1st external review (if any)
- （前回の外部レビューで推奨された案件に従って設計の変更を行ったものを列挙）
- B. Items that have been reduced in cost (if any)
- （以前の設計でオーバースペックだったが、予算削減のためにスペックダウンした項目
- C.Human resources
- 現在のマンパワー（人名）をエフォート（％で表示）付きで記述してください。
- 今後必要とされるマンパワー（人数）を2018年まで1年ごとに表示してください。
- A. Design changes that have been made with the suggestions in the 1st external review (if any)
Date: February 28(Mon) - March 4(Fri), 2011
Location and access: ICRR U-tokyo, Kashiwa campus, 6F large conference room
http://www.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp/access/index_eng.html
Review documents
Subgroup name |
Document number |
Analog Electronics |
|
Cryogenics |
|
Data Analysis |
|
Detector Configuration |
|
Digital system |
|
Input Output Optics |
|
Laser |
|
Main Interferometer |
|
Mirror |
|
Tunnel |
|
Vacuum |
|
Vibration Isolation |
|
Program
2/28 |
|||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
|
|
|
|
9:50-10:05 |
Opening Talk |
T. Kajita |
|
10:05-10:10 |
Introduction of External Review |
S. Kawamura |
|
10:10-12:00 |
Detector Configuration & Roadmap 1 |
K. Somiya, M. Ando |
|
|
Lunch |
|
|
13:30-15:30 |
Detector Configuration & Roadmap 2 |
K. Somiya, M. Ando |
|
|
Coffee Break |
|
|
16:00-18:00 |
Data Analysis |
N. Kanda |
|
3/1 |
|||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
|
|
|
|
10:00-12:00 |
Main Interferometer 1 |
Y. Aso |
|
|
Lunch |
|
|
13:30-14:30 |
Main Interferometer 2 |
Y. Aso |
|
|
Coffee Break |
|
|
15:00-17:00 |
Input/Output Optics |
S. Talada |
|
3/2 |
|||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
|
|
|
|
10:00-12:00 |
Vibration Isolation 1 |
R. Takahashi |
|
|
Lunch |
|
|
13:30-14:30 |
Cryogenics |
T. Suzuki |
|
14:30-15:00 |
Vacuum |
Y. Saito |
|
15:00-16:00 |
Tunnel |
T. Uchiyama |
|
|
Coffee Break |
|
|
Extra talk 1 |
CLIO |
T. Uchiyama |
|
Extra talk 2 |
TAMA SAS |
R. Takahashi |
|
17:30-18:00 |
Geophysics Interferometer |
A. Araya |
|
3/3 |
|||
Time |
Title |
Speaker |
File |
|
|
|
|
10:00-11:00 |
Laser |
N. Mio |
|
11:00-12:00 |
Mirror |
N. Mio |
|
|
Lunch |
|
|
13:30-14:15 |
Analog Electronics |
S. Moriwaki |
|
14:15-15:00 |
Digital System |
O. Miyakawa |
|
15:00-15:30 |
Vibration Isolation 2 |
R. DeSalvo |
|
|
Break |
|
|
18:00-20:00 |
Banquet |
||
3/4 |
|||
|
|
|
|
10:00-12:00 |
Discussion among reviewers 1 |
|
|
|
Lunch |
|
|
13:30-15:30 |
Discussion among reviewers 2 |
|
|
|
Adjourn |
|
|
Reviewers
Name |
Affiliation |
Remarks |
Masaki Ando |
LCGT/ Kyoto University |
Deputy chief of secretariat |
Stefan Ballmer |
LSC/ Syracuse University |
|
Alessandro Bertolini |
LSC/ Albert-Einstein-Institut Hannover |
|
Raffaele Flaminio |
Virgo/ Laboratoire des Matériaux Avancés |
|
Andreas Freise |
GEO/ University of Birmingham |
|
Warren Johnson |
LSC/ Louisiana State University |
|
Seiji Kawamura |
LCGT/ ICRR, NAOJ |
Chief of secretariat |
David Ottaway |
ACIGA/ University of Adelaide |
|
Benno Willke |
GEO/ Leibniz Universität Hannover |
|
Michael E. Zucker |
LIGO-Lab/ Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
Chair |