|
Size: 317
Comment:
|
Size: 2016
Comment:
|
| Deletions are marked like this. | Additions are marked like this. |
| Line 1: | Line 1: |
| === Simulation Tools === | '''[[../|...Up]]''' = Simulation Tools = |
| Line 4: | Line 6: |
| ||Optickle||Matlab||Frequency Domain||Radiation Pressure, 01 mode||Matt Evans|||| | ||Optickle||Matlab||Frequency Domain||Radiation Pressure, 01 mode||Matt Evans||--([[http://ilog.ligo-wa.caltech.edu:7285/advligo/ISC_Modeling_Software|Password protected]])--|| |
| Line 6: | Line 8: |
| ||e2e||C++||Time Domain|| ||Hiro Yamamoto|||| | ||e2e||C++, JAVA||Time Domain|| ||Hiro Yamamoto||[[http://www.ligo.caltech.edu/~e2e/]]|| ----- == Comparison of simulation tools for LCGT == Several simulation tools with theoretical line using LCGT 2007 parameters are compared here, FINESSE, Thomas, Oprickle. Except for FINESSE. *Theoretical: just analytical way shown in [[http://gw.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp:8888/cgi-bin/DocDB/ShowDocument?docid=30|LCGT design document]] on page 14. *FINESSE: 'ps2S' and 'scale meter' commands are used for the unit in m/rHz and 'fig' command are used to produce excitations in frequency domain. FINESSE seems to have a bug of a factor by sqrt(2), but it can be compensated later if you know this information to match other results. *Thomas: Developped by Thomas Corbit. Visual C++ besed, running only Windows machine. This is the first simulation tool which can calculate quantum effect using two-photon modes. *Optickle: Very flexible simulation tool. You can use a full set of Matlab functions. This tool also can calculate full quantum effect. Optickel RF calculation seems to have a bug of a factor by sqrt(2) for the radiatoin pressure noise, but DC readout calculation is OK. This bug can be compensated to put 2*sqrt(2) instead of 2 on the setMechTF function but radiation pressure noise for DC readout will be larger by a factor of sqrt(2) in this case. === BRSE, with loss, radiation pressure noise for LCGT parameters === {{attachment:BRSE_loss_rad.png}} [[attachment:20090930_simall_BRSE_loss_rad.zip]] Optickle RF result is lower by a factor of sqrt(2) than other results due to the bug explained above. |
Simulation Tools
Name |
Platform |
Domain |
Capabilities |
Author |
Web |
Optickle |
Matlab |
Frequency Domain |
Radiation Pressure, 01 mode |
Matt Evans |
|
Finesse |
C? |
Frequency Domain |
Higher order modes |
Andreas Freise |
|
e2e |
C++, JAVA |
Time Domain |
|
Hiro Yamamoto |
Comparison of simulation tools for LCGT
Several simulation tools with theoretical line using LCGT 2007 parameters are compared here, FINESSE, Thomas, Oprickle. Except for FINESSE.
Theoretical: just analytical way shown in LCGT design document on page 14.
- FINESSE: 'ps2S' and 'scale meter' commands are used for the unit in m/rHz and 'fig' command are used to produce excitations in frequency domain. FINESSE seems to have a bug of a factor by sqrt(2), but it can be compensated later if you know this information to match other results.
- Thomas: Developped by Thomas Corbit. Visual C++ besed, running only Windows machine. This is the first simulation tool which can calculate quantum effect using two-photon modes.
- Optickle: Very flexible simulation tool. You can use a full set of Matlab functions. This tool also can calculate full quantum effect. Optickel RF calculation seems to have a bug of a factor by sqrt(2) for the radiatoin pressure noise, but DC readout calculation is OK. This bug can be compensated to put 2*sqrt(2) instead of 2 on the setMechTF function but radiation pressure noise for DC readout will be larger by a factor of sqrt(2) in this case.
BRSE, with loss, radiation pressure noise for LCGT parameters
20090930_simall_BRSE_loss_rad.zip
Optickle RF result is lower by a factor of sqrt(2) than other results due to the bug explained above.